If your company already runs a business app and wants more of its everyday improvements implemented, choose Artie for work in the existing codebase. Gilfoyle, Artie's AI software engineer, takes requests from product, marketing and operations through to tested pull requests that your engineers can review in the repositories you choose.
Lovable offers a different route. It can import an existing app, rebuild it as a Lovable project and let your team keep developing it there. That can be valuable when you want an integrated place to build and host the app. For a brand-new application, that integrated route is a natural fit. For an application with existing users, a database and a working release process, the decision also involves what you want to move.
This comparison is published by Artie and draws on both products' documentation. The recommendation is for a product or operations lead who wants to improve an app the company already runs, with an engineer retaining review of the changes.
Start with the change your business needs
Consider a hypothetical company with a customer onboarding portal. Operations wants a company-size field with the same choices as its CRM. Marketing has legally approved wording to place beneath the annual price. Customers already use the portal, and the engineering team maintains its code in GitHub.
These requests belong in the existing application. The field needs to fit the onboarding flow, and the pricing text needs to appear in the right place. The people asking for the work can explain the business requirement, while an engineer remains responsible for reviewing the implementation.
Gilfoyle's engineering workflow gives those teams a direct way to ask in Slack. Artie's own illustrations include the CRM-matched onboarding field, with a test, and approved annual-pricing copy, each returned as a pull request ready for review. The useful result is a concrete change the engineer can inspect, rather than another request that still needs someone to turn it into code.
Each task starts on a fresh, isolated machine with the selected repository. Gilfoyle writes and tests the code, then opens the pull request. He can work on several tasks in parallel up to the workspace's capacity. For the portal owner, that means the onboarding improvement and the pricing update can be handled as separate changes within the application the team already maintains.
The engineering route requires GitHub and the Claude Code or Codex access your team connects. That coding agent is the engine Gilfoyle uses. The Artie purchase adds the employee workflow around it: intake from business teams in Slack, task-specific work on the repository, testing and delivery for engineer review. Lovable instead charges build usage through credits, including messages sent after an import request, and running the imported app's database and users counts as Lovable Cloud usage. These are different usage models, not evidence that one is cheaper.
Lovable can bring an existing app into its platform
Lovable's project import is a substantive capability. It is available on all plans and accepts a ZIP of code, with guided export routes for Replit, Manus, Bolt, Base44 and v0. A repository downloaded as a ZIP is also a supported starting point.
The import inspects the code, schema and configuration before running anything. Lovable then rebuilds the app on TanStack Start. It says it preserves the same pages, routes and behavior, moves the database into its built-in backend and replaces the previous sign-in system with Lovable authentication. Supported external services, including payments, storage, email and analytics, can stay in place with the required credentials.
Lovable also verifies the result. It builds the project, opens pages and tries a representative flow, such as creating and editing a record. For apps with users, its checks include an imported user verifying their email, setting a password, signing in and seeing their own records. It reports what is ready and what still needs input from the owner.
That is a useful route for consolidating an application into Lovable. Lovable carries out the rebuild and verification, while the owner supplies the data and service credentials it needs. The reason to choose Artie for the onboarding portal is that the business wants changes to its current application, with its current codebase and release process as the starting point.
GitHub support does not mean the same starting point
Both products support work that developers can review. Lovable's GitHub integration provides two-way sync, feature branches and pull request creation. Changes pushed to the active branch sync back into Lovable. Developers can work locally, export the code and deploy outside Lovable. GitHub Enterprise Cloud with data residency and GitHub Enterprise Server are available on Lovable's Enterprise plan.
The distinction for an existing-app buyer appears in Lovable's GitHub FAQ. As checked on November 16, 2026, Git sync always creates a new repository for a project. To start from an existing repository, Lovable directs the owner to download it as a ZIP and import it into a new project. Git sync can then create a repository for that Lovable project.
Gilfoyle's route starts with the repositories you grant him access to. He can read them, create branches and open pull requests in them. The onboarding-field request can therefore enter the team's existing engineering review process as a proposed change to the portal's code.
The choice is about where development starts and what adopting the product entails. Tests, GitHub access and pull requests are useful on both sides. Artie's advantage for this buyer is the direct route from a business request to a tested change in the codebase the company wants to keep using.
An imported app needs a switch-over
Your original application keeps running while you inspect the imported version in Lovable's preview. The import guide then describes the work needed to switch users over: export the latest data when users have stopped using the old app, publish the Lovable project, point the domain to it and update service addresses such as payment webhooks. Records created in the old system after the export are not included in Lovable.
Existing user profiles and records can carry over, including their original IDs and relationships. Passwords and sessions do not. Users verify their email and choose a new password when they next sign in, and the app owner needs to tell them about that change. Lovable does not send that announcement for the owner.
Those are concrete adoption tasks for a portal with active customers. They may be worthwhile when moving the application is itself part of the goal. If the immediate need is an onboarding field and approved pricing copy, Artie's repository-based workflow lets the team commission those changes without making Lovable's import and switch-over process part of the job.
Keep improving the app your team already owns
Gilfoyle's value continues beyond the first request. The same business teams can bring him the next improvement, while engineers review the resulting code. He can also review pull requests, leave findings tied to specific lines and follow those review threads until they are resolved. For production issues, he can inspect connected logs and recent releases, open a fix and check the errors after it ships. These capabilities support ongoing work on the app, with human engineering review still part of delivery.
For a company that wants to move its application into an integrated build-and-host platform, Lovable provides a serious import, verification and Git workflow. For a company that wants more improvements delivered to the application it already runs, choose Artie. Gilfoyle gives business teams a way to turn their requests into tested pull requests in the existing repository, so engineers can focus their review on the change the business actually needs.



